SA¹ú¼Ê´«Ã½

Have you ever had a supervisor who made you question their leadership skills? What are we asking; of course you have! We’ve all been there. Some managers have mastered the art of motivating their teams, while others seem to have taken a course specifically in how not to manage.

EMS crews rely on good leadership; not just for day-to-day operations, but for fostering a supportive and effective environment. Bad supervisors can sap morale, hinder teamwork and make a tough job even harder. So, here are the top 10 signs of a bad EMS supervisor — and hopefully none of these sound like your boss … or you!

The EMS Leader Playbook

Turn personal roots into professional gold: ‘Lead like you mean it’

Laysha Ward teaches public safety leaders how to reframe life experiences into leadership superpowers, develop connection currency and align work-life goals for sustainable success

May 01, 2025 05:25 PM

 · 

Fitch & Associates

1. Poor communication

Communication is the language of leadership. A good EMS supervisor keeps the team informed, but a bad one? They leave you guessing. You might find yourself wondering about changes to protocols or unclear expectations. Bad communication leads to confusion, mistakes and, eventually, resentment. And don’t forget, when communication is lacking, gossip fills the void, creating a toxic work atmosphere.

2. Micromanagement

The micromanager is like an overly attentive backseat driver. They don’t trust anyone else to do things right, so they hover, nitpick and stifle any sense of independence. In EMS, micromanagement kills morale. A good supervisor trusts their crew to handle their responsibilities. After all, isn’t part of a leader’s job knowing when to step back?

3. Lack of empathy

EMS work is demanding, and empathy from leadership goes a long way. A bad supervisor has little regard for personal hardships or struggles. They treat staff as cogs in a machine, not as people. In contrast, an empathetic supervisor understands the pressures their team faces, and offers support. Remember, caring about your people is more than just good manners; it’s a fundamental part of effective leadership.

Grow your leadership skills

4. Inconsistency

Imagine a supervisor who enforces rules differently depending on their mood. One day, they’re by-the-book; the next, they’re turning a blind eye. This inconsistency causes frustration and distrust among the team. Employees want to know what to expect, so a good leader stays consistent and sets a standard everyone can count on.

5. Favoritism

Nothing breeds resentment like favoritism. When a supervisor shows preference for certain staff members, it’s demoralizing for everyone else. The favored ones might get the best shifts or special treatment, while others work twice as hard for half the recognition. Good leaders recognize each team member’s strengths without playing favorites.

6. Sidestepping accountability

Bad supervisors are quick to take credit when things go well, but when there’s a problem? Suddenly, it’s anyone else’s fault but theirs; they are experts at throwing people under the bus to save themselves. In EMS, where teamwork is essential, a leader who can’t take responsibility is a dangerous liability. Good leaders stand by their team and own up to their mistakes.

7. Lack of vision

It’s hard to follow a leader who doesn’t know where they’re going. A bad supervisor has no clear vision and, as a result, the team lacks direction. A strong leader, however, has a vision for what the team can achieve and inspires others to reach it. In EMS, that vision can be as simple as building a cohesive, supportive crew that provides exceptional care.

8. Refusal to delegate

Some supervisors seem to think that doing everything themselves is the mark of a great leader. But by hoarding tasks, they rob team members of growth opportunities and overload themselves in the process. In EMS, delegation isn’t just smart; it’s essential. When a leader delegates, they trust the team to step up, take responsibility and, ultimately, excel.

9. Failure to support growth

A supervisor who doesn’t encourage growth is holding the team back. EMS is a career of constant learning, and a good leader supports the professional development of their team. A bad supervisor, however, is content to let everyone stagnate, fearing that someone might outshine them. But true leadership is about lifting others up, not holding them back.

10. Unprofessional behavior

When a leader gossips, makes inappropriate comments, or treats people poorly, they set a terrible example. Professionalism is vital in EMS, where trust and respect can make or break a team. Leaders need to model the behavior they expect, holding themselves to the highest standard. When they don’t, they lose respect — and, often, the loyalty of their team.

Great leaders don’t just manage — they inspire

So, there you have it — the top 10 signs of a bad EMS supervisor. If you’ve recognized your own boss in any of these traits, don’t lose heart. Remember, every bad leader offers a lesson in what not to do, and you can use that insight to become a better leader yourself one day. Great leaders don’t just manage people; they inspire, support, and bring out the best in their team. Here’s hoping your supervisor is one of the good ones — or that you can be the leader that breaks the cycle.

WATCH | ‘Leadership is an action': 10 signs of a bad EMS supervisor

SA¹ú¼Ê´«Ã½ is using generative AI to create some content that is edited and fact-checked by our editors.